Savings banks face aftershocks
Since then, the beleaguered sector has faced more than its fair share of trials, tribulations and heavy-handed restructuring, with 15 more savings banks suspended, over 27 trillion won ($23.3 billion) in sector assets gone, and more than a million customers at a time being blocked from accessing their deposits.
Such a trial by fire has inevitably altered the landscape of the domestic savings bank sector.
Now a handful of financial holding companies and others including Hyundai Group have purchased 10 of the ailing lenders, creating room for the new owners to emerge as dominant forces in the market. Meanwhile, savvy customers are increasingly keeping their savings bank deposits under the government’s guarantee threshold, while the high deposit rates once equated with the sector have all but disappeared.
However, the crisis is not yet over, as all six savings banks that received a provisional pass during last September’s wave of suspensions must still survive a final evaluation this year. Failure would result in suspension or restructuring.
Over the last 12 months, customers’ trust in the savings bank sector has been fundamentally shaken by waves of suspensions that felled an average of four institutes each quarter. This triggered several bank runs as savers feared losing their deposits, and uncovered a well of corruption running deep through the industry.
It also caused the sector’s total assets to shrink from 86.8 trillion won at the end of 2010 to 59.7 trillion won as of the end of September, when the most recent data was released. This scaled back the size of total assets to where they were four years ago. By the same token, savings banks’ total deposits plunged from 76.8 trillion won at the end of 2010 to 51.9 trillion won at of the end of last September.
Now history appears to be repeating itself as Korea’s leading banking groups return as owners of the suspended savings banks.
Before 1997, commercial banks often owned small mutual savings and financial companies - later renamed savings banks - but the chaos of the Asian financial crisis caused many to be sold or fail. Now financial holding companies have jumped in to fill the ownership vacuum, with KB, Woori, Shinhan, Hana and BS all acquiring savings banks within the last year.
They are expected to stabilize the sector and rebuild trust with the public by using the massive amounts of capital at their disposal, as well as their brand power, to turnaround the ailing banks. Industry observers cite Woori FG Savings Bank, formerly Samhwa Mutual Savings Bank, as a successful model given its renaissance after being acquired by Woori Finance Holdings last March.
“Our strategy of attracting customers who fail to qualify for loans at commercial banks, as well as our moves to lend large sums in conjunction with commercial banks, have been effective so far,” said a Woori employee.
Customers are also wising up, with more keeping their savings bank deposits under the government guarantee limit of 50 million won per account. According to the Korea Deposit Insurance Corporation, 134,186 customers had deposits of more than 50 million won as of 2010, while 6.89 trillion won was not guaranteed by the government. These numbers have subsequently shrunk to 48,000 customers as of last September, with 3.18 trillion won not shielded by a governmental guarantee.
But the aftershocks of last summer’s purge may once again throw the sector into turmoil as six savings banks that escaped being suspended are having their cases reviewed by the Financial Supervisory Service to see whether they have made good on their promises. Those with dangerously low BIS capital adequacy ratios may yet be suspended.
By Lee Jung-yoon [email@example.com]
More in Finance
[NEWS ANALYSIS] As foreigners rush back, market does an about-face
CU gets into the foreign exchange transaction business
Kospi hits another record high despite Covid spike
5-day winning streak ends as Kospi drops 0.62 percent
Debt is the latest hot product being pushed into the market