Court announces compensation for worst oil spill
The residents of Taean County in South Chungcheong were dismayed over what they called “unfairly low” amounts.
The Daejeon District Court’s Seosan branch ruled yesterday in a preliminary hearing that the victims of the accident should be compensated with 734.1 billion won ($693.3 million). The amount is five times higher than a preliminary assessment of 182.4 billion won by the International Oil Pollution Compensation Funds, but far lower than the compensation demanded by people affected by the disaster.
At 7:15 a.m. on Dec. 7, 2007, the Hebei Spirit, a 146,848-ton oil tanker from Hong Kong, was struck by an 11,800-ton Samsung Heavy Industries barge about 15 kilometers (9.3 miles) northwest of Mallipo in South Chungcheong. Due to the accident, more than 10,000 tons of fuel oil spilled into the sea. It was the country’s worst oil spill. Previously the worst was in 1995 when the Sea Prince ran aground 8.25 kilometers off the shore of Yeosu, South Jeolla, spilling about 5,000 tons of crude oil into the South Sea.
The court said 413.8 billion won will be given to residents who directly suffered from the spill, while another 217.4 billion will be provided to the central and local governments for maritime restoration projects.
Another 102.9 billion won will be compensation for the cleaning operation, the court said.
According to the ruling, the Hebei Spirit will pay up to 145.8 billion won; the International Oil Pollution Compensation Funds - three intergovernmental agencies that pay compensation for oil spills - will pay up to 329.8 billion won; Samsung Heavy Industries will pay about 5.6 billion won; and the government will pay about 248.7 billion won.
The preliminary hearing is a process to check the feasibility of the compensation requested by the residents in Taean. The amount that the court has calculated will be used as the standard in future civil suits.
Yesterday’s ruling was the first-ever court calculation of the damages since the incident, said Kim Yong-cheol, the presiding judge of the case.
“When the amount is finalized, the National Assembly will approve budgets and the residents will be compensated,” he said.
Of the 734.1 billion won, the court judged that the damages to the fishing industries was about 687.1 billion won and 46.1 billion won was considered damage for nonfishing industries, including tourism and restaurant businesses.
Since February 2011, the Seosan branch court had been studying the damages in the region including Taean, the most damaged area, with 50 experts. It held 30 meetings to study the case. Since the amount of compensation calculated yesterday was much less than Taean residents’ demands, a series of civil suits are expected.
The International Oil Pollution Compensation Funds could also appeal the court’s decision.
The residents, the Hebei Spirit and International Oil Pollution Compensation Funds have 14 days to file appeals with the Seosan branch court.
“We waited five years and this is what we get,” said Mun Seung-il, secretary general of an association of the Taean oil spill victims. “Residents who are not fishermen were awarded almost nothing. The court largely reflected the position of the International Oil Pollution Compensation Funds in the ruling and ignored the positions of the residents.”
Five years after the spill, residents in the west coast area close to South Chungcheong have not yet recovered from the damage. The local economy fell as tourists avoided the region and the amount of fish caught rapidly decreased.
Taean County is the region suffering most. The number of tourists to Taean in 2007 was 20.8 million but only 9.2 million tourists visited last year. Taean sold 14,146 tons of marine products in 2007, but the number fell to 7,345 ton last year.
“We hired five to six workers before the oil spill but now we only hire two on weekends,” a sushi restaurant owner at Mallipo Beach in Taean complained.
“The compensation was my last hope, but the compensation for people who are not engaged in fishing is just too low,” he said.
“I appealed to the court, to the government and even to Samsung,” said Heo Ok-sun, a 64-year-old resident who made a living harvesting sea shells from the area’s mud flats for 40 years. “Who should I trust now?”
The court said Heo is entitled to 3 million won in compensation.
Shin Mun-ung, a 44-year-old owner of a pension, said yesterday that he could not run his business for more than one year due to the effects of the oil spill. “I filed a petition to receive 13.7 million won in compensation,” he said. “But the court awarded me nothing, not even a single coin.”
Shin said he was not alone.
About 3,000 people who were not fishermen sought compensation individually without hiring lawyers or delegating the process to the association of the victims. Most of them, however, lost their claims.
Concerns were also high about the residents’ health. Taean County’s Environmental and Health Center conducted a survey last year of 10,000 residents. According to the report, the people who participated in the oil spill cleaning operation were reported to have more respiratory diseases than residents who didn’t.
“We are carefully following the effects of the oil spills on the residents’ health,” said Eom Gwi-heum, a senior official of the center.
By Shin Jin-ho, Kwon Sang-soo [email@example.com]