Can we please atop calling S&P an ‘agency’?Now that the Justice Department has filed its lawsuit accusing McGraw-Hill Cos. and its Standard & Poor’s unit of fraud, I have a plea for my fellow scribblers in the press: Please stop calling S&P a “ratings agency.”
Call it a ratings company, or a rater, or a publisher, or an opinion merchant. Take your pick. Or come up with your own moniker clearly signaling that S&P is a commercial enterprise that makes its money by selling rating services to bond issuers.
The term “agency” makes S&P seem like it’s an arm of the government, which it isn’t. The U.S. government formally deems some rating companies, including S&P and Moody’s Investors Service, as nationally recognized statistical rating organizations. But they are not government agencies, or any other kinds of agencies.
They are for-profit corporations. That is all. We should stop exalting them.
Jonathan Weil A Bloomberg View columnist