Apple pilloried over display model policy

Home > Business > Industry

print dictionary print

Apple pilloried over display model policy


The latest iPhones including XS, XS Max and XR on display at the company’s Apple store in Garosugil in Gangnam, southern Seoul, on Nov. 2. [YONHAP]

Just before the Fair Trade Commission comes to a decision on whether Apple has violated domestic fair trade laws, Korean phone distributors are calling the tech giant out for being the only phone manufacturer in the country that makes them pay for display phones in their stores.

The Fair Trade Commission (FTC) is due to hold a meeting in mid-December after two years of investigating accusations against Apple and finally decide whether the company indulged in unfair practices. Some complaints are that Apple charges mobile carriers for repair and advertising costs of Apple products.

On Wednesday, the Korea Mobile Distributors Association (KMDA) accused the company of doing something that no other handset maker did in Korea. “Apple doesn’t let us sell iPhones at all if we don’t purchase the demo phones needed for store displays,” read a statement from the KMDA. “Other manufacturers provide the display phones themselves, and come to collect them later.”

According to the association, Apple even charged retailers for the costs of building shelves for display models and controlled where the promotional posters for new products were placed. Most of the demo devices are priced at around 70 percent of the market price. Distributors say they also had to purchase demo iPads and Apple Watches.

iPhones are getting more costly, which could be a factor in the distributors going public with complaints against the company.

In the past, Apple phones cost no more than 1 million won ($883). Last November, the iPhone X launched just three weeks after the iPhone 8 with a 1.42 million won price tag for a 64 gigabyte model. With the release of the iPhone XS, XS Max and XR on Nov. 2, iPhone prices have reached new highs. The iPhone XS Max is selling for more than 30 percent higher than the iPhone X at 1.97 million won for a 512 gigabyte model.


A document by Apple sent to retailers specifically states that they have to purchase demo iPhones. [JOONGANG ILBO]

“Previously, I spent around 1.1 million won on demo devices for Apple’s new products,” said a 53-year-old owner of a wireless store in Jongno District, central Seoul.

Branches of the three major mobile carriers - SKT, LG U+ and KT - are the main distributors of mobile phones in Korea.

“But recently, with Apple products becoming more expensive, the costs I have to bear have risen tremendously,” he said.

The owner estimated that he spent nearly 5 million won on purchasing demo phones for Apple’s newest models.

According to industry estimates, each mobile retailer spends around 2.9 million won a year purchasing Apple demo phones. This means that Apple will earn around 25.5 billion won in total sales of demo phones from the country’s 8,800 wireless stores.

“We are not trying to sue Apple right away at this point, but rather figure out who holds responsibility,” added a KMDA spokesman. “Mobile carriers may be responsible for allowing Apple to pursue such unfair practices, leaving distributors to pay for the costs.”

Korea is not the only country that has investigated Apple for unfair practices. This July, Japanese authorities called out the tech giant for antimonopoly practices that included forcing local mobile carriers to subsidize iPhone prices to boost sales. In 2016, France sued Apple for $55 million over unfair practices that also involved unfair contracts.

Apple has not released an official response to the KMDA’s complaints.

Sales of Apple’s new products have been less than stellar, which is also fueling dissatisfaction among distributors. According to industry estimates, the number of customers buying Apple’s three newest models between Nov. 2 and Nov. 7 was only 60 percent of the number that purchased Apple’s iPhone X and iPhone 8 in their first week last November.

Log in to Twitter or Facebook account to connect
with the Korea JoongAng Daily
help-image Social comment?
lock icon

To write comments, please log in to one of the accounts.

Standards Board Policy (0/250자)